Reallocation of Stakeholders: Exit, Engagement and the Measurement of Impact

A purpose-driven stakeholder can leave a harmful firm for a cleaner one (exit) or stay and pay for mitigation (engagement), depending on what the market offers. We model these outside options with a matching model, where a rise in purpose reallocates stakeholders. Multiple stakeholder groups and harm that scales with firm size are needed to rationalize the coexistence of exit and engagement in the data. Engagement impacts a firm directly; exit spills over across firms. Because exit registers as noncompliance, a firm-level difference-in-differences understates the per-stakeholder mitigation effect of a rise in purpose; a compliance-adjusted estimator recovers it despite spillovers.